Continental Navy

Silas Cleveland. Silas Cleveland, Jr. was born in Canterbury, CT on 17 March 1756, son of Silas Cleveland, Sr. and Elizabeth Hyde. He enlisted on 25 June 1776 at Canterbury in Captain Asa Bacon’s Company of Col. John Chester’s Regiment. They were sent through Norwich to New London then to New York where he served until his discharge at Peekskill on 25 December 1776. Chester’s Regiment was part of the 6th Battalion of Connecticut Troops attached to General Wadsworth’s Brigade who served at Long Island and White Plains. Subsequent to the time Cleveland “worked rigging the vessel” in the River Thames, during the Fall of 1778 “at Thanksgiving time”, he joined the Continental Navy frigate Confederacy’s contingent of Marines as Private. His youngest brother Isaac (1770-1863) of Brooklyn, Windham, CT recalled that Silas went on board the Confederacy in November of 1778. Silas attested to Marine Oliver Roger’s pension application, as did his older brother Solomon Cleveland (1754-1823) who was married to Hannah Sharpe, younger sister of Silas’ wife Lois. Captain Silas Cleveland lived in Canterbury, Windham Co. in 1832 when his pension application #S12486 was initially denied for claiming that he was only “a hand” on board the Confederacy. Eventually his pension was approved and issued on 12 April 1833. Cleveland’s application intriguingly lists a number of the ship’s officers and crew and posting onboard. It indicates he was rated as “Ship’s Corporal” due to the influence of his uncle Frederick Curtis, Master at Arms.  Frederick Curtis was married to Laurenah Hyde, the sister of Silas’ mother Elizabeth. Distant relative and retired U.S. Navy Chief Warrant Officer James Doran correctly identifies Silas Cleveland as “Ship’s Corporal” from his pension testimony and schools us on the significant difference between that rate and the previously noted incorrect “Corporal of Marines” stating; “A Corporal of Marines is in fact a Marine whose Chain of Command goes through the Commanding Officer of the Marine Detachment. A Ship’s Corporal is a junior Petty Officer of the Navy who reports to the Ship’s Master Arms at Arms and thence to the First Lieutenant of the Ship.” Cleveland’s pension application indicates he was discharged from the frigate Confederacy at Chester, PA in August 1779, prior to that vessel’s capture by the British. A 1782 deed suggests that Silas Cleveland was acquainted with Benjamin Durfee of Canterbury, father of the boy Asa Durfee who died at sea on the Confederacy. One source suggests that Silas Cleveland achieved the rank of Captain of the Fifth Regiment of Connecticut Militia. On 22 March 1793, Silas Cleveland married thirty-five year old Lois Sharpe of Pomfret, Windham, CT. They had at least three sons, all born in Hampton, NY; Mason born 25 February 1796, John born 4 September 1797 and Chauncey born 26 February 1799. His son Hon. Chauncey Fitch Cleveland, who became Governor of Connecticut, remembered “Silas Cleveland was much like his father, a man of wonderful memory and fine abilities. During the Revolutionary war my father (Silas) then a young man, about Sept.1, 1780, went to Bethel, Vermont, with the intention of settling there. When in the woods at work with a man by the name of David Stone, a band of Indians from Montreal captured them and took them to Canada. Silas was so copper-colored, they dressed him in their paint and feathers, Stone they killed. My father they kept six months, when they put him in the British Prison called the Stone Jug, in Montreal, Canada; there he was kept six months longer and then exchanged. He dwelt awhile in Bethel and then returned to Hampton”. Cleveland is included among a “Return of Prisoners sent from the Province of Quebec for Exchange” in Publication M246 of the National Archives. He is listed with prisoners of war from New York and New England who were returned in September 1781 by way of Lake Champlain.  Cleveland’s own testimony in his pension affidavit notes that after “British Indians took me prisoner” at Bethel, he was first carried to Lake Champlain, then to St. John’s and afterwards to St. Regis where he was held until 5 February 1781. At that time he was carried to Montreal and confined until 20 August 1781 before his exchange was executed on 18 September 1781. Silas Cleveland spent most of his life at Hampton in the occupation of farming. His wife Lois Sharpe Cleveland died five days after her fifty-fourth birthday on 29 June 1811. At 84 years old, Silas Cleveland was living in Hampton when he died on 24 September 1840.

Jeheil Comstock. Jeheil Comstock, oldest son of Samuel Comstock of Lyme and Elizabeth Ackley of East Haddam, was likely born in 1756 as he was christened on 17 October of that year in Hadlyme, CT. His siblings included Samuel, Cyrus, Silence Sears, and the youngest Elizabeth born in 1762. According to A Comstock Genealogy by Cyrus Ballou Comstock, Jeheil served in Captain Jones’ militia company from 24 August to 30 October 1777 with younger brother Samuel prior to his service as one of the crew of the Continental Frigate Confederacy. He is listed on the Frigate Confederacy Riggers’ Returns of 1778-1779. Jeheil Comstock is also listed as Corporal on the Confederacy in Silas Cleveland’s pension file #S-12486, when he would have been about 23 years old. In 1788 he resided in Lyme, CT. Jeheil Comstock was living in Royalton , Niagra Co., NY in 1832 at age 75. His will was dated 13 December 1832 and probated 29 April 1833. He had no relatives at time of his death except his younger brother Samuel of Cheshire Co., NH.